In the ever-evolving landscape of supernatural romantic comedies, few titles manage to blend magical chaos with heartfelt character dynamics as seamlessly as "If Witch, Then Which?" (originally titled *Majo nara, Donchi*). Written and illustrated by the talented Daiki Takei, this manga is a hidden gem that revitalizes the "childhood friend" trope by injecting it with high-stakes sorcery and a compelling dual-heroine narrative. For fans of series like *Nisekoi* or *The Quintessential Quintuplets*, but with a distinct paranormal twist, this is a must-read.
The Plot: A Magical Tug-of-War
The story centers on Haru, an average high school student whose life is anything but ordinary thanks to his two childhood friends: Manaka and Kaguya. While they appear to be normal teenagers to the outside world, they are actually powerful witches representing two opposing sides of the magical spectrum.
Manaka is a "White Witch," wielding magic derived from purity and light, though her execution is often clumsy and leads to unintended, often hilarious, consequences. On the other side is Kaguya, a "Black Witch," whose powers are rooted in darkness and complexity. The crux of the story lies in a magical decree: a witch’s power is significantly amplified and stabilized by a "contract" with a human partner. Naturally, both girls have set their sights on Haru to be their familiar and romantic partner.
The narrative follows Haru as he navigates the literal and metaphorical crossfire of their magical rivalry. Every chapter brings a new supernatural mishap—from love potions gone wrong to spatial distortions in the classroom—all while Haru struggles with his growing feelings for both girls. The title itself, *If Witch, Then Which?*, serves as the central question of the series: in a world of light and shadow, which path (and which girl) will Haru ultimately choose?
Demographic and Genre
"If Witch, Then Which?" is firmly rooted in the Shonen demographic. Serialized in Kodansha’s *Weekly Shonen Magazine* (and later *Magazine Pocket*), it utilizes classic Shonen tropes such as the "indecisive but kind" protagonist, high-energy slapstick humor, and a touch of fan service. However, it elevates the genre by focusing heavily on the emotional weight of the characters' choices rather than just the magical battles. It sits comfortably at the intersection of Supernatural, Romantic Comedy, and School Life.
Key Themes: Choice, Duality, and Identity
Beyond the magical hijinks, the manga explores several profound themes:
1. The Burden of Choice: The "Which" in the title isn't just about romance; it’s about the weight of decision-making. Haru represents the bridge between two worlds, and his choice carries the potential to change the balance of the magical community.
2. Duality of Nature: Through the White and Black Witch dichotomy, Takei explores the idea that "good" and "evil" aren't as binary as they seem. Manaka’s light can be destructive, and Kaguya’s darkness can be protective. This nuance adds a layer of Seinen-lite depth to a Shonen framework.
3. The Evolution of Childhood Bonds: A recurring theme is how relationships change as we grow. The transition from childhood playmates to romantic interests is complicated by their magical responsibilities, forcing the trio to confront the reality that they can't stay children forever.
Art Style and Tone
Daiki Takei’s art is a standout feature. The character designs are vibrant and expressive, capturing the frantic energy of the magical mishaps. The contrast between the ethereal, soft aesthetic of the White Magic and the sharp, gothic undertones of the Black Magic creates a visual feast that keeps the reader engaged. The tone shifts effortlessly from lighthearted comedy to moments of genuine romantic tension, ensuring the pacing never feels stagnant.
Why You Should Read It
If you are looking for a manga that offers more than just a standard harem setup, *If Witch, Then Which?* provides a refreshing take on the genre. It balances its supernatural elements with a grounded emotional core, making the reader care deeply about the outcome of Haru’s impossible choice. It’s a story about magic, yes, but more importantly, it’s a story about the magic of human connection. Whether you’re a veteran otaku or a newcomer to the Shonen rom-com scene, this series offers a spellbinding experience from start to finish.
📖 Leer online en Donmanga:
➡️ If Witch, Then Which – Leer Manga
